How to Build Accountability That Works for You and Your Team

As we get closer to a new year, it's time to ask: What do we want to do differently?

We take time for an individual or team check-in, looking at what we need to let go of, what we want to keep doing, and where we want to grow. We have the conversation, write down our intentions, and sometimes even leave with a plan we are excited about.

And that’s where it gets complicated.

We understand the importance of moving forward, but how do we stay accountable for the things we said we would do? And as leaders, how do we encourage accountability without becoming the person who keeps checking, reminding, and following up with everyone?

Work with the system, not against the system

Let me start here: sometimes, the way we try to hold ourselves accountable works against us.

We see someone who gets up early, follows their list, and finishes what they planned, and we get upset with ourselves for not being able to do the same. Or we find a system that works for us and assume it should work for everyone on our team.

But have we paused to notice what actually helps us follow through as a team and as individuals on the team?

Think about something you already do consistently. What makes it work? Where do you see it already working as a team?

Before adding another system, notice the ones you have already created, sometimes without realizing it.

Notice how you respond to expectations

In her Four Tendencies framework, Gretchen Rubin explores how people respond to outer expectations, such as a deadline from a client, and inner expectations, such as a goal we set for ourselves. Her framework describes four tendencies: Upholders, Questioners, Obligers, and Rebels, each with a different response to those expectations.

One useful question to take from this is:

What helps me follow through on a commitment?

Maybe you recognize this thought: “Why is it so easy for me to deliver on my promises to my clients, team, or family, but so difficult to keep a promise to myself?”

For some of us, knowing someone is waiting outside the gym at 6 a.m. makes a difference. For others, the commitment we make to ourselves is enough to get us there.

Take a moment to reflect: what helps you follow through? Is it completing your to-do list because you made a commitment to yourself and know why it matters to you? Or does sharing that list with someone who will ask about your progress make it more likely you’ll complete it?

Think about where this already works in your life, whether you run on your own or show up because a friend is waiting for you. What is your system, and how could you use it for something you’re struggling to follow through on?

Build accountability through peer systems

If knowing someone will check in helps you move forward, make that part of your system.

This is one way peer-to-peer systems can strengthen accountability in teams. People have someone to think with, share progress with, and speak honestly with when something gets in the way.

Find an accountability partner

An accountability partner can be a colleague, another leader, a founder, or someone working toward a goal of their own. You don’t need identical goals, but you do need a shared commitment to the relationship.

Some partners meet to discuss progress. Others state what they want to accomplish, work independently during the same block of time, and check in before leaving. Experiment with what works for both of you.

You can also create a partnership around one specific goal for a limited time, such as completing a project, writing a series of articles, or practicing a leadership skill.

My accountability partner and I have met weekly for years; we are both business founders in different spaces. We use our weekly conversations to discuss business goals, challenges, and aspirations, and since we know each other so well, we challenge each other to bring our best, notice blind spots, and keep sharing resources. For example, my accountability partner urged me to trademark Walking Mastermind when I had just started doing it. Having that space gives us an opportunity to think together, ask questions, and return to the things we said mattered to us. Most importantly, we remind each other where we have made progress, noticing what moved, what didn’t, and what we want to do next.

Sign up here to learn how to get our accountability partner list to co-create a strong relationship that lasts for years.



Accountability peer group

A peer group or mastermind can create space to explore challenges, hear how others approach similar situations, and return to your commitments over time. Peer group systems can provide a facilitated space for that reflection, practice, and continued learning.

One of the things I have appreciated about mastermind conversations is the opportunity to learn with people whose businesses and experiences are different from mine. Sometimes, someone asks a question I would never have asked myself, and suddenly I see my situation differently.

But a good conversation alone doesn’t create accountability. It is the meaningful connection between peers that a good mastermind group facilitator or group creates, where the peers care for each other, and then accountability follows. If the group is too task-oriented, the conversation might be nice, but the group will not see progress and growth.

Build a peer group around a real need

For many of our clients, organizational change is an area where leaders are no longer sure how to tackle it. We identified a group of operations leaders who were unsure how to move from reactive to proactive, and they began meeting with us once a week. The group coach facilitated peer conversations where they brought challenges, explored them together, and committed to influencing change or developing new processes together. Within a few months, the company noticed a significant difference in how quickly processes moved forward.

Sometimes, connecting around a specific need or challenge can bring peers together to solve real challenges.

Make a commitment visible

A few years ago, after a run, I posted my first “On the Run” video and shared that I would post a video every time I ran. I have been doing that for 8 years now. As a team or a leader of a team, put your commitment out there, on Slack, social media, or Teams, and even though you know most people don’t sit and wait for you to be accountable, what kind of culture do you want to lead: the one that says, “Anyway, no one cares about it,” or “We put it out there, so we’d better be accountable for it”? Knowing that you put it out there will make your commitment visible and make it hard not to follow through as part of your team culture or the culture you want to create as a leader of a team.

Make progress playful and visible

Some teams and leaders thrive on healthy competition.

With those teams or leaders, we create a point system for consistently addressing their goals.

The harder the goal, the more points it earns; the easier it is, the fewer points you give it.

Some accountability partners compete against each other as well. Take the idea and mold it for your own system: make it fun, make it challenging, and celebrate progress. Yet, be thoughtful about what you count! The number of completed tasks doesn’t necessarily tell you whether the work moved forward or whether people worked well together.

And when you don’t, be curious

Before deciding someone isn't accountable, step back and get curious; prepare to have a conversation about what is getting in their way.

One of the biggest challenges for teams is that the leader and team leave the meeting feeling everyone is aligned, only to realize they are not!

Was the commitment clear? Did they agree to it, or did everyone assume they had? Do they have the time, authority, and information to act? Are competing priorities pulling them in different directions?

An accountability partner cannot resolve an unclear decision or an unrealistic workload.

As a leader, you can begin with:

“We agreed on this, and it hasn’t moved forward. What’s getting in the way, and what needs to happen next?”

Then make the next agreement clear: who owns the action, when it will happen, and how others will know if something changes.

At ADVAgo, we help leaders and teams build these conversations into the work. Peers practice asking each other about commitments, raising concerns early, and giving feedback, so follow-through doesn’t depend on the leader being part of every conversation.

Start with one commitment

Sometimes we push too many rocks, so we get nowhere.
What if you pushed only 3 rocks as a team that will create the most meaningful impact and also is achievable?

What would make it easier to follow through? A clearer next step? Time protected in the calendar? A conversation with a peer? A decision about what you need to stop doing to make room for it?

Choose one approach, try it, and return to see what you learned.

You may already have more insight into what works for you than you realize. Start there, and give your team room to explore the same question.

What is the biggest challenge you're facing right now that peer accountability systems could help move your leaders, your team, and even your organization forward?

Next
Next

Assess the Yes